Chorales in Baroque Music: A Comparison of J.S. Bach and Handel

Which chorale is exuberant and which one is statelier?

Compare J.S. Bach's "Wachet Auf" and Handel's "Hallelujah Chorus".

Answer:

J.S. Bach's "Wachet Auf" is more stately, while Handel's "Hallelujah Chorus" is more exuberant.

When comparing the two chorales, it is evident that J.S. Bach's "Wachet Auf" has a more solemn and reverence tone compared to Handel's "Hallelujah Chorus".

Bach's "Wachet Auf" is commonly performed during the season of Advent, adding to its mystical and reverential tone. The intricate harmonies and melodic development in Bach's chorale create a sense of anticipation and contemplation, making it a more statelier piece.

On the other hand, Handel's "Hallelujah Chorus" is known for its powerful and celebratory nature. The grandeur of the chorus, along with the famous "Hallelujah" theme, evokes feelings of joy and triumph. The dynamic contrasts and dramatic shifts in Handel's composition contribute to its exuberant character.

In conclusion, while both chorales are masterpieces of the Baroque era, Bach's "Wachet Auf" leans towards a more solemn and stately expression, whereas Handel's "Hallelujah Chorus" is exuberant and celebratory in nature.